Surprise Videos - Gay (39,711)

muscle daddy in business suit with big balls and fat cock giving himself a cum load in his own face

muscle daddy in business suit with big balls and fat cock giving himself a cum load in his own face

GayJack 10 months ago

Brock is surprised at first, watches Mike jerking his fat cock

Brock is surprised at first, watches Mike jerking his fat cock

TwinksNHunks 4 months ago

Best Friend's Dick In My Face

Best Friend's Dick In My Face

TwinksNHunks 1 year ago

Superman Submits

66% 0:39 / 27:41

Superman Submits

FapHouse 6 months ago

Chosen Family Dinner - Cliff Media Productions

Chosen Family Dinner - Cliff Media Productions

xHamster 2 months ago

Big Dick Energy - Paixao And Matheuz Henk Double Team Nico Zetta

Big Dick Energy - Paixao And Matheuz Henk Double Team Nico Zetta

Eporner 1 year ago

He surprises me by showering

He surprises me by showering

xHamster 1 week ago

The experience you wanted

50% VR 1:07 / 37:10

The experience you wanted

VirtualRealGay 3 years ago

Bareback Orgy in Milwaukee

53% HD 1:22 / 15:52

Bareback Orgy in Milwaukee

BarebackPlus 9 years ago

Hot Prostate Play & Deep Creampie Action With Ethan Chase And Shawn Rhimes

Hot Prostate Play & Deep Creampie Action With Ethan Chase And Shawn Rhimes

Fapnado 1 year ago

Surprise For Steele | LOGAN Vol. 2

64% HD 1:15 / 30:20

Surprise For Steele | LOGAN Vol. 2

FunsizeBoys 2 years ago

0003 Army - Lukas Hu. and Duscian Part 2

60% 1:01 / 12:16

0003 Army - Lukas Hu. and Duscian Part 2

FapHouse 1 month ago

”Jayden Marcos Ditches Girlfriend for Omar Zayden's Heavy Surprise Encounter”

”Jayden Marcos Ditches Girlfriend for Omar Zayden's Heavy Surprise Encounter”

Fapnow 1 month ago

Deep Massage Part 1

65% HD 1:01 / 23:09

Deep Massage Part 1

FapHouse 7 months ago

Stepbrothers' Secrets Brock Kniles and Derek Kage

Stepbrothers' Secrets Brock Kniles and Derek Kage

xHamster 2 months ago

Cum On Bro! Cameron Jones COVERS David Slinger With Cum!

Cum On Bro! Cameron Jones COVERS David Slinger With Cum!

xHamster 8 months ago

Ultra-cute super-steamy student showcases off her purple underpants under her mini-skirt, with surprise close-up

Ultra-cute super-steamy student showcases off her purple underpants under her mini-skirt, with surprise close-up

MenGem 11 months ago

Jet Lagged Twink Caught Jerking Flips Hunk Stepbro - NextDoorStudios

Jet Lagged Twink Caught Jerking Flips Hunk Stepbro - NextDoorStudios

Some.Porn 11 months ago

Surprise Two penises For U

Surprise Two penises For U

GayCK 5 years ago

”Forget My Sister! Fuck Me!”

”Forget My Sister! Fuck Me!”

Trashreality 10 months ago

I Fuck My Boyfriend and My Gay Friend Joins Us

I Fuck My Boyfriend and My Gay Friend Joins Us

xHamster 3 months ago

Passionate sex in the bath

Passionate sex in the bath

GayXPS 2 weeks ago

”Alaric Spence expects the unexpected”

”Alaric Spence expects the unexpected”

Zatube 9 months ago

Nothing compared to being side by side with him in the sauna

Nothing compared to being side by side with him in the sauna

GayXPS 3 months ago

FamilyDick: When Stepdads Get Surprisingly Sexual

FamilyDick: When Stepdads Get Surprisingly Sexual

GayPorn 2 years ago

Hot Hard Fuck: Nick Harper Tops Zach Douglas

Hot Hard Fuck: Nick Harper Tops Zach Douglas

xHamster 7 months ago

Muscle massage with surprise cumshot - homemade video cumshot homemade massage

Muscle massage with surprise cumshot - homemade video cumshot homemade massage

SexTubeSpot 1 year ago

Jonathan can’t believe he’s finally losing his virginity, but...

Jonathan can’t believe he’s finally losing his virginity, but...

TwinksNHunks 4 months ago

What Happens When 2 Teen Men Lock Themselves in the Shower

What Happens When 2 Teen Men Lock Themselves in the Shower

4Gay 1 year ago

LE - Daddy's Holiday Surprise

LE - Daddy's Holiday Surprise

2BGay 2 years ago

Detention Isn't for You

Detention Isn't for You

Fapnado 1 year ago

”Vincent Grey & Miles Fallon Discover an Unexpected Surprise in Their Room”

”Vincent Grey & Miles Fallon Discover an Unexpected Surprise in Their Room”

Trashreality 1 week ago

Colby Knox: Steamy Sauna Surprises

Colby Knox: Steamy Sauna Surprises

GayPorn.video 6 days ago

Chunky booty amateur getting fucked under the bridge

Chunky booty amateur getting fucked under the bridge

HOMO.XXX 4 years ago

Men: Eager Bottom's Cumface Surprise

Men: Eager Bottom's Cumface Surprise

GayPorn.video 1 year ago

Twink Stepson Gets Fucked Hard By Naughty Step-father & Big Dick Step Uncle - Family Dick

Twink Stepson Gets Fucked Hard By Naughty Step-father & Big Dick Step Uncle - Family Dick

xHamster 2 years ago

Cameron Kincade's first time domination: a wild blowjob with a big cock

Cameron Kincade's first time domination: a wild blowjob with a big cock

AllBoner 2 months ago

Surprise pulverizing alongside first-timer

Surprise pulverizing alongside first-timer

UrGayPorn 1 year ago

Spike Wheel Surprises in Anal Adventure

Spike Wheel Surprises in Anal Adventure

GayPorn.video 11 months ago

Stepbro's Gay Surprise - Jake Finally Gets the Cock He Craves, Fucked Hard by a MILF

Stepbro's Gay Surprise - Jake Finally Gets the Cock He Craves, Fucked Hard by a MILF

GayxXxWorld 10 months ago

Turks for Beginners (directors Cut Turks for Beginners)

56% HD 1:01 / 1:00:53

Turks for Beginners (directors Cut Turks for Beginners)

FapHouse 1 year ago

Bad Boy Camp - Chapter 1

Bad Boy Camp - Chapter 1

xHamster 6 months ago

Dude happily blasted in the butt prior to a facial

Dude happily blasted in the butt prior to a facial

HOMO.XXX 4 years ago

Bondo Gods 3

AbGay 1 year ago

Daddy's Holiday Surprise

Daddy's Holiday Surprise

GayJaVu 8 months ago

Straight men has gay surprise cock suck

Straight men has gay surprise cock suck

DrTuber 3 years ago

Family reunion

PornSigma 4 weeks ago

Clueless Stepbrother Gets A Valentine's Day Surprise : Stepbro Helps Him Unbox His Package

Clueless Stepbrother Gets A Valentine's Day Surprise : Stepbro Helps Him Unbox His Package

Eporner 1 year ago

”Jayden Marcos Ditches Girlfriend for Omar Zayden's Fat Surprise Encounter”

”Jayden Marcos Ditches Girlfriend for Omar Zayden's Fat Surprise Encounter”

Trashreality 7 months ago

John Gets a Boner - Part 2

53% HD 0:39 / 8:11

John Gets a Boner - Part 2

FapHouse 4 months ago

Coach Vehicle and Shag take a wild ride in the park, with a hot creampie surprise!

Coach Vehicle and Shag take a wild ride in the park, with a hot creampie surprise!

GayX 9 months ago

Horny Kam Stone Mistook Hunky Oliver Marks For a Dude From the Sex-date Site & Fucked Him

Horny Kam Stone Mistook Hunky Oliver Marks For a Dude From the Sex-date Site & Fucked Him

XGroovy 1 year ago

First Time Bottoming! Latinos Outdoor Raw Fucking in the Dunes!

65% HD 1:01 / 40:45

First Time Bottoming! Latinos Outdoor Raw Fucking in the Dunes!

FapHouse 8 months ago

Kameroon Magic Ride

Kameroon Magic Ride

xHamster 11 months ago

”The Unconfident Speaker”

”The Unconfident Speaker”

Trashreality 1 year ago

Eluan & Olaf

BelamiOnline 5 years ago

”Danny Shine & Skylar Finchh surprise Mick Weston with a bday booty”

”Danny Shine & Skylar Finchh surprise Mick Weston with a bday booty”

Zatube 5 months ago

Femboy Surprises Stepdaddy in the Shower

Femboy Surprises Stepdaddy in the Shower

xHamster 1 month ago

Cock hungey farmer gives stranger a bj on the field

Cock hungey farmer gives stranger a bj on the field

AllBoner 3 years ago

Suck my big dick my friend and i will fuck you bareback with end creampie by surprise

Suck my big dick my friend and i will fuck you bareback with end creampie by surprise

xHamster 4 months ago

KEN'S SURPRISE HJ

KEN'S SURPRISE HJ

MenGem 2 years ago

Max Mabry's Morning Surprise BAREBACK

Max Mabry's Morning Surprise BAREBACK

Pornzona 4 months ago

Twunk Sonnie Gets Nailed Rock-hard By Nasty Step-daddy & Giant Manmeat Step Uncle - Family Manmeat

Twunk Sonnie Gets Nailed Rock-hard By Nasty Step-daddy & Giant Manmeat Step Uncle - Family Manmeat

4Gay 3 months ago

”Muscled military general Jake Cruise dominated by the strong soldiers”

”Muscled military general Jake Cruise dominated by the strong soldiers”

TransHero 3 months ago

BoundMuscleJocks: Brogan Endures Dire Callahans Ruthless Clothespin And Ball Torment

BoundMuscleJocks: Brogan Endures Dire Callahans Ruthless Clothespin And Ball Torment

FetishShrine 6 days ago

Hairy hunk ass fingered and blown

Hairy hunk ass fingered and blown

DeegX 3 years ago

Colby Chambers finds his friend Lucas Angel Naked at the Pool and FUCKS him HARD and RAW

Colby Chambers finds his friend Lucas Angel Naked at the Pool and FUCKS him HARD and RAW

GayXPS 1 year ago

”Charming Nanny Hope Loves Shanes Massive Surprise”

”Charming Nanny Hope Loves Shanes Massive Surprise”

429Men 8 months ago

Valentine's Day surprise - hot romantic threesome

Valentine's Day surprise - hot romantic threesome

GayXPS 1 week ago

ADAY TRAUN Penetrate Firm Jess by Surprise in Madrid

ADAY TRAUN Penetrate Firm Jess by Surprise in Madrid

GayVids 3 years ago

GuysInSweatpants - Dax’s unprotected Surprise (Dax Daniels pounds Masturbate Hunter)

GuysInSweatpants - Dax’s unprotected Surprise (Dax Daniels pounds Masturbate Hunter)

2BGay 2 years ago

Vincent wakes up horny as fuck, and wants his friend's stepdad's cock

Vincent wakes up horny as fuck, and wants his friend's stepdad's cock

TwinksNHunks 1 year ago

Ricky Larkin fucks frustrated writer Jake Porter

Ricky Larkin fucks frustrated writer Jake Porter

HOMO.XXX 5 years ago

Mike Maverick and Hans Berlin's raw glory hole encounter: a surprise fuck

Mike Maverick and Hans Berlin's raw glory hole encounter: a surprise fuck

BoyFriendTV 1 year ago

Office punishment after caught fucking in the library

Office punishment after caught fucking in the library

GayXPS 1 year ago

”Nudist Thanksgiving”

”Nudist Thanksgiving”

TransHero 5 months ago

”Aaron Trainer Puts His Heavy Prick In Jock Aaron Perez's Booty”

”Aaron Trainer Puts His Heavy Prick In Jock Aaron Perez's Booty”

ThePornstar 1 year ago

My Sleepwalking Pal Got a Surprise Suckjob

My Sleepwalking Pal Got a Surprise Suckjob

XXXShake 2 years ago

Hairy Hunks Banged in 3way

Hairy Hunks Banged in 3way

GayXPS 4 months ago

Latest Czech hunt ends with a spectacular orgasm

Latest Czech hunt ends with a spectacular orgasm

HOMO.XXX 3 years ago

Virtual Sexuality -bareback-

Virtual Sexuality -bareback-

xHamster 1 month ago

Virgin Birthday Surprise

Virgin Birthday Surprise

TwinksNHunks 2 years ago

”BLACKS ON BOYS JR Bronson & Fame”

”BLACKS ON BOYS JR Bronson & Fame”

Rainblow 1 year ago

A Surprise For Uncle – Jace Chambers, Nick Milani

A Surprise For Uncle – Jace Chambers, Nick Milani

GayVids 2 years ago

Testing Out Two New Bitches

Testing Out Two New Bitches

xHamster 6 months ago

19 Year Old Stud First Bound and Edged

19 Year Old Stud First Bound and Edged

xHamster 3 months ago

Surprise Birthday Bash

Premium HD 22:17

Surprise Birthday Bash

Video naked guys at dr office gay The guy gasped then moaned in surprised.

Video naked guys at dr office gay The guy gasped then moaned in surprised.

Eporner 4 years ago

Family reunion

TwinksNHunks 1 year ago

JT Stryder & Seamus O'Rilley in Surprise Dessert XXX Video

JT Stryder & Seamus O'Rilley in Surprise Dessert XXX Video

OurGay 2 years ago

Gorgeous Hunk Surprises Doorman BF

Gorgeous Hunk Surprises Doorman BF

GayXPS 1 year ago

Parent's Holiday Surprise

Parent's Holiday Surprise

2BGay 2 years ago

Home alone lads fulfill one another’s gay desires

Home alone lads fulfill one another’s gay desires

GayPorn 3 years ago

”Aaron Perez fucks his sexy step-daddy, Aaron Trainer”

”Aaron Perez fucks his sexy step-daddy, Aaron Trainer”

TransHero 3 months ago

Insatiable Stepfather Alex Killian Surprises Son With Rod Throating

Insatiable Stepfather Alex Killian Surprises Son With Rod Throating

MenGem 1 year ago

Welcome, Ya Filthy Pig Bottom

51% 4K 1:08 / 34:13

Welcome, Ya Filthy Pig Bottom

PigBottoms 1 year ago

Beno ekers raw birthday surprise: 2024 hd 1080p twink action with bareback anal and big cock cumshots!

Beno ekers raw birthday surprise: 2024 hd 1080p twink action with bareback anal and big cock cumshots!

ManPorn 1 year ago

The large Surprise (Vintage homo 1980)

The large Surprise (Vintage homo 1980)

GayJaVu 8 months ago

Closeted Jock Seduces Nerdy Twink During Study Session

Closeted Jock Seduces Nerdy Twink During Study Session

xHamster 4 years ago

Step-daddy & Step-uncle take turns pounding Jax Thirio's tight ass - Family Manmeat

Step-daddy & Step-uncle take turns pounding Jax Thirio's tight ass - Family Manmeat

GayVD 2 weeks ago

Sam Ledger greets boyfriend with a flirty pose

Sam Ledger greets boyfriend with a flirty pose

FetishShrine 1 year ago

Passionate sex in the bath

Passionate sex in the bath

TwinksNHunks 5 months ago

Surprise In The Hotel Apartment

Surprise In The Hotel Apartment

GayVids 2 years ago

Oops! Straight Friend Surprised by Intense Gay Blowjob and Raw Anal – Voyeur POV

Oops! Straight Friend Surprised by Intense Gay Blowjob and Raw Anal – Voyeur POV

GayxXxWorld 10 months ago

Dex Fails the Self-Suck Challenge So Stepdad Jon Deepthroats Him Instead

Dex Fails the Self-Suck Challenge So Stepdad Jon Deepthroats Him Instead

xHamster 2 weeks ago

Surprise!! This Str8boy Loves The "D"

Surprise!! This Str8boy Loves The "D"

GayCK 7 years ago

Family Dick - Uncle Damian Night giving head for Jack Waters

Family Dick - Uncle Damian Night giving head for Jack Waters

GayTube.site 2 years ago

Twinks and hunks in a 3some with Santiago, Rodri, and Tommy

Twinks and hunks in a 3some with Santiago, Rodri, and Tommy

HOMO.XXX 5 years ago

Str8 Guy Wakes to Surprise Rimjob

Str8 Guy Wakes to Surprise Rimjob

TwinksNHunks 2 years ago

Surprising Sex In Prague

Surprising Sex In Prague

MrGay 4 years ago

Shredded newcomer fucked in the ass in POV

Shredded newcomer fucked in the ass in POV

HOMO.XXX 5 years ago

A young guy becomes a girl, a smooth beautiful ass with a surprise - a big dick!

A young guy becomes a girl, a smooth beautiful ass with a surprise - a big dick!

xHamster 2 years ago

Danny Shine and Skylar Finchh surprise Mick Weston with a birthday ass

Danny Shine and Skylar Finchh surprise Mick Weston with a birthday ass

UrGayPorn 1 year ago

”Michael Boston surprised when sees DeAngelo Jackson's gay big black dick”

”Michael Boston surprised when sees DeAngelo Jackson's gay big black dick”

IFuckedYourGF 1 year ago

Ballsack Challenge

Ballsack Challenge

Fapnado 1 year ago

Mateo Fernandez destroying Sean Harding's ass with his giant cock

Mateo Fernandez destroying Sean Harding's ass with his giant cock

HOMO.XXX 5 years ago

Johny Polak is our new dude, happy to show off and enjoying interaction with Mr. Hand Jobs. Mr. Jobs will slowly start undressing Johny, removing his dick from his undies, and what a surprise to find out one nice erect big snake, just ready to receive

Johny Polak is our new dude, happy to show off and enjoying interaction with Mr. Hand Jobs. Mr. Jobs will slowly start undressing Johny, removing his dick from his undies, and what a surprise to find out one nice erect big snake, just ready to receive

SissyFlix 1 year ago

Gloryhole Surprise 480p

Gloryhole Surprise 480p

GayJaVu 8 months ago

Hunk stepdad showing his stepson how to play a pool

Hunk stepdad showing his stepson how to play a pool

GayXPS 2 years ago

Surprised by His Friend's Hidden Package in a Wild Gay Sex Scene – Staxus

Surprised by His Friend's Hidden Package in a Wild Gay Sex Scene – Staxus

GayxXxWorld 10 months ago

1 2 3 4 5

39,711 results found

Related categories

Surprise Cum In Mouth 69 Creampie Surprise POV Threesome Amateur Facial Homemade Threesome Watching Taboo Fantasy Amateur POV Threesome Creampie Facial Snatch POV Facial Therapy Swallowing Dirty Talk Gloryhole Cum Swapping Creampie Eating Birthday

Narrow your search

sleepover surprise surprise boner surprise cum surprise fuck bisexual surprise surprise threesome gay surprise surprise rimjob creampie surprise trans surprise blindfolded surprise surprise anal femboy surprise 18+ surprise cum in mouth massage surprise tranny surprise surprise trans asian surprise surprise cock surprise friend

Categories Pornstars

Categories Pornstars

Parents

hookupcritic.org uses the "Restricted To Adults" (RTA) website label to better enable parental filtering. Protect your children from adult content and block access to this site by using parental controls.

© 2026 hookupcritic.org. All rights reserved.

© 2026 hookupcritic.org. All rights reserved.